Jump to main navigation, main content

Archived entry | Matt Wilcox .net

YouTube embeded player includes search bar. That's a user interface screw-up.

YouTube have started including a “brand bar” with search field in their embedded players. That’s a bad idea for two reasons; firstly embedded players are in the context of another site, and shoving a YouTube bar in the player quite easily ruins carefully crafted designs: “hey look at the video! Let me grab your attention!”. Secondly, this is an embedded player - it’s there because the author of the page including the video thinks the content of the video is relevant to their audience. Given that is the only use case for embedding a video, why would anyone want to search YouTube for a different video at that point? By all means include this new functionality, but do it after the video has played, you know, when it’s relevant. Not before.

This entry is 1 years, 99 days, 5hrs old; its contents may have become outdated, irrelevent or inacurate. Linkrot may have occured.

Comments

skip to comment form
  1. Matt Wilcox posted 2hrs, 11min, 32sec after the entry and said:

    You can disable the bad by adding a little code into the embed mark-up. It's a welcome feature, but the point remains that the default should not be to have the bar there in the first place. It's not needed.

    http://lifehacker.com/5101887/get-rid-of-youtubes-embedded-search-bar

  2. Matt Wilcox posted 3 days, 17hrs, 31mins after the entry and said:

    YouTube have now stopped putting the search bar into the embedded players smiley icon: smile

Care to share a thought?

Who are you?

What have you got to say?

note: I have used various methods to reduce comment spam. Your browser must send a HTTP_REFERER header in order to successfully post a comment.

From the archives

Other enteries filed under:

My Two Cents

Site information

Built with valid XHTML and CSS, designed with web standards and accessibility in mind. Best viewed in a modern browser [Firefox, Safari, Opera]